Great project software does not just hold tasks. It shows who is blocked, which work matters most, and whether your plan still matches reality. The best tools in 2025 combine flexible planning, collaboration in context, strong automations, and reporting you can trust. This guide reviews leading options, what they do best, and how to decide based on your team type and maturity.
Evaluation framework
We scored platforms across six practical criteria:
- Planning views. List, board, timeline, and Gantt support plus dependencies and baselines.
- Collaboration. Comments, approvals, file previews, and notification control.
- Automation. Rules, triggers, and templates that remove busywork.
- Reporting. Workload, capacity, custom dashboards, and export options.
- Knowledge and docs. Embedded docs, specs, and references next to tasks.
- Adoption and cost. Time to value, seat model, and change management overhead.
Top picks and quick takes
| Tool | Key features | Pricing start | Best for | Verdict |
| Asana | Tasks, timelines, goals, automations | Tiered | Cross functional teams | Easy to adopt with clean workflows |
| Monday.com | Boards, dashboards, templates | Tiered | Ops and marketing | Flexible building blocks for many workflows |
| ClickUp | Docs, tasks, dashboards, goals | Tiered | Startups and SMBs | All in one depth at strong value |
| Jira | Backlogs, sprints, dev workflows | Tiered | Software teams | Agile standard with dev integrations |
| Notion | Docs, databases, tasks, wiki | Tiered | Docs first teams | Powerful doc plus task hybrid |
| Smartsheet | Grid, Gantt, resource management | Tiered | PMO and operations | Spreadsheet friendly with scale |
| Wrike | Work intelligence, proofs, approvals | Tiered | Marketing and PMO | Strong intake and creative workflows |
| Basecamp | Simple projects, message boards | Flat plan | Small teams | Minimal overhead for straightforward work |
Prices change. Confirm on vendor sites before you decide.
What each platform does best
Asana
Strengths: Clear tasks and timelines, lightweight goals, strong automation rules, and easy adoption across non technical teams.
Best fit: Cross functional projects where marketing, product, and ops collaborate.
Watchouts: Deep portfolio budgeting and classic Gantt needs may require upgrades or another tool.
Monday.com
Strengths: Boards that become dashboards, simple intake forms, and versatile templates for ops, marketing, and support.
Best fit: Operations heavy teams that want to shape the tool to their process.
Watchouts: Complex work hierarchies and long chain dependencies can get busy.
ClickUp
Strengths: Ambitious all in one that blends docs, tasks, dashboards, goals, and whiteboards.
Best fit: Startups and SMBs that want a single system for most work.
Watchouts: With power comes complexity. Invest in clear conventions and training.
Jira
Strengths: Deep agile workflows, backlogs, sprints, and dev integrations.
Best fit: Software teams that need issue types, story points, and dev automation.
Watchouts: Non technical users can struggle without a simplified layer.
Notion
Strengths: Flexible docs and databases, knowledge base, and simple task tracking in one place.
Best fit: Docs first teams and product squads that co author specs next to work.
Watchouts: Classic portfolio reporting requires thoughtful setups.
Smartsheet
Strengths: Spreadsheet like grids, Gantt, resource management, and robust enterprise controls.
Best fit: PMOs and operations teams that live in grids and Gantt charts.
Watchouts: Collaboration feels more structured. Creative teams may prefer a board first tool.
Wrike
Strengths: Intake, proofs, approvals, and reporting.
Best fit: Marketing and creative teams with many assets and stakeholders.
Watchouts: Admin configuration can get heavy. Plan your taxonomy first.
Basecamp
Strengths: Simplicity. Message boards, to dos, and a shared schedule.
Best fit: Small teams and client projects that need little ceremony.
Watchouts: Limited advanced planning compared to full PM suites.
How to pick based on your team
Marketing and go to market
Pick flexible templates and easy forms. Monday.com and Wrike stand out. Asana is a safe default when adoption speed matters most. Use dashboards for campaign status and asset approvals.
Product and engineering
Jira remains the agile standard. If you want a docs first flow that blends specs, tasks, and lightweight sprints, Notion plus a simple backlog view can work. Connect releases to product analytics for better readouts.
Operations and PMO
Smartsheet shines for grid and Gantt heavy programs. Asana portfolios or Monday.com dashboards also work when work types vary. Prioritize resource views and intake to tame the flow of requests.
Agencies and client work
Basecamp is easy when projects are simple. Asana and Monday.com add better reporting and automation when you scale to many clients.
Migration checklist
- Map old fields and statuses to the new tool. Archive clutter so you do not import noise.
- Create conventions for naming, owners, and due dates. Add a short style guide in the wiki.
- Build templates for the most common project types.
- Automate intake with a form. Route work to the right team automatically.
- Pilot with one team for two weeks. Iterate based on real friction.
- Train managers to read dashboards and coach off the same view.
- Measure adoption weekly for the first month.
Reporting that leaders value
- Workload by person and team
- On time completion rate by project type
- Cycle time by request type
- Risked tasks that block critical milestones
- Forecast vs actual for the next two sprints or two weeks
Common pitfalls and how to avoid them
- Too many fields. Keep only what drives planning and reporting. Archive the rest.
- No shared conventions. Publish a one page guide for names, tags, and statuses.
- Dashboards nobody reads. Build two or three standard views and teach managers how to use them.
- Tool sprawl. If you add a second PM tool, document why and how data flows between them.
Security and access
Use SSO, role based permissions, and project level sharing. Limit admin rights to a small group. Turn on audit logs if you run a formal PMO. For clients, create guest access that hides internal chatter and cost information.
Integrations that matter
Connect your PM tool to Slack or Teams for notifications with context. Sync with your source control and release pipeline if you run software projects. Export key fields to BI so leadership sees the same truth in executive dashboards.
FAQs
Which tool is best for non technical teams that want something simple.
Asana and Monday.com are quick to adopt and cover most needs without heavy setup.
Which tool is best for software teams.
Jira remains the standard. If your team is docs first, Notion plus a light backlog can work.
How should we track capacity.
Use workload views for near term weeks and a high level capacity model for the quarter. Keep it simple or the model will go stale.
Do we need to move everything at once.
No. Migrate one or two active projects, learn, and then roll the pattern to the rest.
Picking the Perfect Tool
You do not need a perfect tool. You need a shared way to plan, collaborate, and report. Pick the platform that your team will actually use, define a few conventions, and make your dashboards the single source of truth. If you represent a PM platform and want your product considered for future updates, reach out to our team.
Leave a Reply